Noggin wrote: Tue Jan 13, 2026 7:12 pm
Is it the difference between the standard MT09 and the SP ?? I've seen some that loved the 09 so much and others like you guys that hated it!
Although TBF, I've often fallen in love with marmite bikes
Stock suspension on most bikes is effing terrible these days, but Yamaha do seem to be the worst of the bunch in this respect by some distance!
09 SP adds Kayaba forks and an Ohlins shock which both add a level of adjustability and control, but there is an inherent "overly upright, rearward weight bias" on the 09 and all its derivatives that I have ridden, that is hard to get away from... It makes them properly flight, like NEEEEEED a steering damper AND a careful right wrist flighty when pushing on...
Having owned a lot of the bikes suggested so far in this thread, and ridden most of them... I'm going to now suggest my leftfield choice, which of course is one I currently own myself...
OK so the tank range isn't great (but not as bad as it could be, I get 120-130 miles typically), but otherwise it's a stunner... Very comfy riding position, superb chassis, very confident handling, the engine is a stunner and the gearbox is an absolute peach (yes, I really am saying that about an American bike!). They're not a light bike, sure, but then the standover isn't particularly tall for a naked bike anyway so it's easy to flat foot and the only time you notice the weight is if you have to move it around on your driveway for instance... As soon as you're going, the weight disappears. They make a glorious sound with an aftermarket can on, and you're highly unlikely to see another on your travels! I absolutely adore mine... It's the best "feel good" bike I've ever owned, and I've owned some pretty exotic bikes and some serious high performance machines in my time too.
Oh, and the seat to bar reach is pretty short for a relatively big bike. There's quite a few ladies on them in the facebook owners groups. It's not as short seat to bars as an MT-07/09/10 but it's not far off, and is shorter than just about anything else suggested so far in this thread. Also pretty easy to fit a taller rise bar to if you want to (my mate did), the brake and clutch lines and all wiring from the bars is long enough to accommodate a taller rise bar easily.
It's also one bike I'd suggest that the 100hp French limit wouldn't actually ruin the fun on too, as whilst you can rev it to 9k, there's absolutely no need to, with a wall of torque all the way from 1500rpm to the redline, I rarely take mine above 6k even when I'm making real progress, and just pottering about I'm usually shifting up around 4k...
Even Henry Cole seems to agree with me apparently!