Would you have an electric car if you had the money for a new car and were in the market for one?

[Tomcat]

If you'd asked me a few years ago I'd have said definitely no. Inadequate charging infrastructure, too expensive, too many doubts about battery longevity and range anxiety. But those things are starting to change, and since most of our car mileage is fairly local (rarely do more than 100 miles on a single trip) it could be viable. Maybe if I'm still alive by the time the diesel SEAT turns up its toes, we'll see.

[Taipan]

Fuggers!


My wife said to me today that she's pleased for me as she knew the Tesla wasn't right for me. Which is kinda odd as she seemed miffed I was buying the Jag!? She did admit she was pleased we had a convertible again.

[Horse]

Swedish study


Battery Health After 62,000 Miles
Kia e-Niro – 64kWh 97.25%
Hyundai Kona – 64kWh 97.18%
Kia EV6 – 77.4kWh 95.95%
Volvo XC40 – 69kWh 94.70%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh. 94.35%
BMW i3 – 120 Ah 94.77%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh 93.53%
Tesla Model 3 – 60.5kWh 93.34%
Audi e-tron 50 – 71kWh 93.02%
Audi e-tron 55 – 95kWh 92.93%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.88%
Tesla Model 3 – 78.8KWh 92.83%
Tesla Model S 92.80%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.77%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.60%
Tesla Model X 92.52%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.27%
Tesla Model Y – 78.8kWh 92.18%
Audi Q4 e-tron – 77kWh 92.18%
Volkswagen ID3 – 58kWh 91.7%

[Count Steer]

Swedish study


Battery Health After 62,000 Miles
Kia e-Niro – 64kWh 97.25%
Hyundai Kona – 64kWh 97.18%
Kia EV6 – 77.4kWh 95.95%
Volvo XC40 – 69kWh 94.70%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh. 94.35%
BMW i3 – 120 Ah 94.77%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh 93.53%
Tesla Model 3 – 60.5kWh 93.34%
Audi e-tron 50 – 71kWh 93.02%
Audi e-tron 55 – 95kWh 92.93%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.88%
Tesla Model 3 – 78.8KWh 92.83%
Tesla Model S 92.80%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.77%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.60%
Tesla Model X 92.52%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.27%
Tesla Model Y – 78.8kWh 92.18%
Audi Q4 e-tron – 77kWh 92.18%
Volkswagen ID3 – 58kWh 91.7%

Got a link? Be interesting to know the sample size of each model* (and the validity of quoting to 2 decimal places). It looks odd when you see the variability of results from one manufacturer but then you see it's pretty much a fraction of a % for most of them.

90%+ is pretty good though. Maybe manufacturers should state 'miles per charge at 90% of manufactured capacity'.

* and the elapsed time to reach the 62,000 miles....and the charging regime....and....

[KungFooBob]

I imagine it also doesn't take into account the hidden overhead that all EV batteries have.

On my i4 there's around 2kwh that is excluded from the capacity you are shown as available. The battery management systems will add some of this back in as the battery deteriorates.

The i3 was BMWs first leccy car and had a large hidden number of kwh, because they just didn't know how the battery was going to last long term, that's probably why the i3 figure looks so good.

[Horse]

Swedish study


Battery Health After 62,000 Miles
Kia e-Niro – 64kWh 97.25%
Hyundai Kona – 64kWh 97.18%
Kia EV6 – 77.4kWh 95.95%
Volvo XC40 – 69kWh 94.70%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh. 94.35%
BMW i3 – 120 Ah 94.77%
Polestar 2 – 78kWh 93.53%
Tesla Model 3 – 60.5kWh 93.34%
Audi e-tron 50 – 71kWh 93.02%
Audi e-tron 55 – 95kWh 92.93%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.88%
Tesla Model 3 – 78.8KWh 92.83%
Tesla Model S 92.80%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.77%
Skoda Enyaq iV – 77kWh 92.60%
Tesla Model X 92.52%
Volkswagen ID4 – 77kWh 92.27%
Tesla Model Y – 78.8kWh 92.18%
Audi Q4 e-tron – 77kWh 92.18%
Volkswagen ID3 – 58kWh 91.7%

Got a link? Be interesting to know the sample size of each model* (and the validity of quoting to 2 decimal places). It looks odd when you see the variability of results from one manufacturer but then you see it's pretty much a fraction of a % for most of them.

90%+ is pretty good though. Maybe manufacturers should state 'miles per charge at 90% of manufactured capacity'.

* and the elapsed time to reach the 62,000 miles....and the charging regime....and....

ish

Link to a news item:
https://www.drive-electric.co.uk/news/u ... lth-study/

Which says:

Data from the 2025 Battery Performance Index, produced by electric vehicle battery diagnostics specialist Generational, analysed more than 8,000 electric cars and vans across 36 manufacturers.

Article links to:
https://generational.ac/2025-battery-performance-index/

Who are ...
https://generational.ac/about-us/

[Horse]

Swedish study


Battery Health After 62,000 Miles
Kia e-Niro – 64kWh 97.25%
...
Volkswagen ID3 – 58kWh 91.7%

90%+ is pretty good though.

As.you say, how they're used may have an effect.

However, if - just as a f'rinstance - they had 200 miles range when new, to drop 6-19 miles isn't too bad.

Google says:

Over 100,000 kilometers, a well-maintained vehicle’s fuel consumption typically increases by only 2% to 5%.