I don't actually disagree with you at all Spin. What I need (or needed) from a bike is something that covers distance, 2-up, with luggage, comfortable,commutes during the week, low maintenance, wide service intervals and good on rubbish roads etc. The 1150GS did all that*. I decided it was too big, heavy etc so got an F800GS...and hated it. Its not just engine size...I put 18k miles on a CX500 in a year.The Spin Doctor wrote: ↑Sat Aug 21, 2021 12:09 pm
It was in response to the 'lacking cubes' comment about the Vulcan. That motor - in ER6 form - is the basis of one of the mainstays of the lightweight racing class and they're only slow in comparison with the litre bikes! They aren't THAT much slower than the supersports. And the XV535 meets the 'lazy ride' criteria without needing a car engine.
I agree - bikes aren't sensible... and I'd never tell someone not to ride something they want to ride... my AR80 was a pure impulse purchase and still one of the more fun bikes I've owned. So was the Gixxer750 and though I'm glad I owned it, it was a bit of a chore to own.
But unfortunately, the industry has done a very good job on selling the idea that riders need huge engines under them. They've done it with sports bikes, they have done it with tourers, they've done it with cruisers and they've done it with adventure bikes. And most of the time the bike is either compromised by weight or performance you can't use (power limiters in the lower gears, for instance).
If I could ride anything I wanted, costs be damned, I'd likely go for a TZR250 because of the sheer blast of riding a lightweight two-stroke.
Unfortunately, they don't make 'em any more, there aren't any left at a sensible price and I couldn't afford the fuel anyway
So my two 600cc bikes are 'sensible' because they are work bikes (the classic CB250RS is a bit of an indulgence), they were inexpensive to buy and have cost very little to run... but I love both of them!
But, if you're going to have a bike that you don't actually need, that isn't particularly practical why let sense rule? Pottys thread about his Rudge even got me pondering on getting something silly like a 50 year old Rocket 3/Trident. You know, don't go, don't stop, vibration white-finger and endless spannering. Madness...but probably fun.
So, if I'm to have a cruiser it might as well be a planet-eating heavyweight rather than a vaguely 'sensible' one.
* I miss that bike.